%0 Conference Paper %1 brunet06 %A Brunet, G. %A Chechik, M. %A Easterbrook, S. M. %A Nejati, S. %A Niu, N. %A Sabetzadeh, M. %B Workshop on Global Integrated Model Management (GaMMa'06) at the 28th International Conference on Software Engineering %C Shanghai, China %D 2006 %E ., 20-28 May 2006. %K merging model %T A Manifesto for Model Merging %U http://www.cs.toronto.edu/~sme/papers/2006/GaMMa06-Brunet.pdf %X If a modeling task is distributed, it will frequently be neces- sary to merge models developed by dierent team members. Existing approaches to model merging make assumptions about the types of model to be merged, and the nature of the relationship between them. This makes it hard to compare approaches. In this paper, we present a manifesto for re- search on model merging. We propose a framework for com- paring dierent approaches to merging, by treating merge as an algebraic operator over models and model relationships. We specify the algebraic properties of an idealized merge operator, as well as related operators such as match, di, split, and slice. We then show how our framework can be used to compare existing approaches by applying it to two of our own research projects on model merging. We show how this analysis permits a detailed comparison of approaches, reveals the key features of each, and identies weaknesses that require further research. Most importantly, the frame- work emphasizes the need to make explicit all assumptions about the relationships between models, and indeed to treat model relationships as rst class objects.

@inproceedings{brunet06, abstract = {If a modeling task is distributed, it will frequently be neces- sary to merge models developed by dierent team members. Existing approaches to model merging make assumptions about the types of model to be merged, and the nature of the relationship between them. This makes it hard to compare approaches. In this paper, we present a manifesto for re- search on model merging. We propose a framework for com- paring dierent approaches to merging, by treating merge as an algebraic operator over models and model relationships. We specify the algebraic properties of an idealized merge operator, as well as related operators such as match, di, split, and slice. We then show how our framework can be used to compare existing approaches by applying it to two of our own research projects on model merging. We show how this analysis permits a detailed comparison of approaches, reveals the key features of each, and identies weaknesses that require further research. Most importantly, the frame- work emphasizes the need to make explicit all assumptions about the relationships between models, and indeed to treat model relationships as rst class objects.}, added-at = {2008-01-03T21:51:56.000+0100}, address = {Shanghai, China}, author = {Brunet, G. and Chechik, M. and Easterbrook, S. M. and Nejati, S. and Niu, N. and Sabetzadeh, M.}, biburl = {https://www.bibsonomy.org/bibtex/27518dbc82f02617833f04532a4ffce39/neilernst}, booktitle = {Workshop on Global Integrated Model Management (GaMMa'06) at the 28th International Conference on Software Engineering}, description = {Contains Steve's operators for model management}, editor = {., 20-28 May 2006.}, interhash = {74e7290cf1565881f267b6c503389a39}, intrahash = {7518dbc82f02617833f04532a4ffce39}, keywords = {merging model}, month = May, timestamp = {2008-01-03T21:51:56.000+0100}, title = {A Manifesto for Model Merging}, url = {http://www.cs.toronto.edu/~sme/papers/2006/GaMMa06-Brunet.pdf}, year = 2006 }